Home California Fire Chief Disputes Claims District Failed to File Reports With State

Fire Chief Disputes Claims District Failed to File Reports With State

by ECT


According to the California State Controller’s Office, the East Contra Costa Fire Protection District (ECCFPD) is one of 126 special districts and cities who did not file mandatory financial documents to the State of California which was due October 18, 2012.

ECCFPD Chief Hugh Henderson disputes the claim stating they did file proper paperwork and says it was filed last October.

“Our records show that report was sent certified mail on October 26, 2012.  We are currently trying to confirm this with the State Controller’s office,” said Henderson.

While no penalties are technically issued at this time, should the ECCFPD not file paperwork by the Dec. 31 deadline, auditors might be assigned to the district while the Attorney General’s Office have the option notifying the fire district that it will forfeit $5,000 in state funds.

“Transparency in financial reporting – including public salaries – is necessary to protect communities against the misuse of taxpayer dollars and other abuses of public trust,” said Controller John Chiang.

According to the Controller’s Office, within Contra Costa County, the City of Hercules missed the deadline along with Los Medanos Community Hospital District.

Here is the official Press Release:


State to Audit Cities and Special Districts that fail to file financial records

SACRAMENTO – State Controller John Chiang today sent letters to 126 local governments that have failed to file financial and accounting reports required under State law. The letters went to nine cities and 117 special districts, giving each entity the deadline of December 31, 2013, to file the delinquent documents.

“Transparency in financial reporting – including public salaries – is necessary to protect communities against the misuse of taxpayer dollars and other abuses of public trust,” said Controller Chiang.

Under Government Code section 53891, local governments are required to file a report of financial transactions with the State Controller’s Office, which include figures on revenues, expenditures, and long-term debt, within 90-110 days of the end of the fiscal year. Each report noted in the Controller’s letter is more than a year overdue, during which time the agencies ignored a penalty-free grace period, as well as written notification – delivered via certified mail – warning that assessment of monetary penalties is forthcoming.

The Controller publishes financial reporting instructions on his website annually. Following the 2010 scandal in the City of Bell, he amended the filing instructions to include detailed reports of employee wages and benefit costs. That data is now used to support the Controller’s website dedicated to employee compensation – publicpay.ca.gov.

In his letter, Chiang noted that repeated failures to file may indicate serious internal control problems at the local level. In many of the Controller’s recent audits, internal control deficiencies either caused or were symptoms of serious fiscal distress for local governments. Internal controls include separation of powers between budgeting and check-writing, avoiding potential conflicts of interest in hiring or contracting, and other measures designed to protect the integrity of a local government’s finances.

The letter urges non-compliant cities and special districts to file their delinquent reports by December 31, 2013, or be subject to an audit to obtain the missing data. Public agencies which have demonstrated a chronic inability to file their financial reports may be subject to an additional audit of their internal controls and other fiscal management practices.

“My office’s audits of Bell, Stockton and other fiscally-distressed public agencies have highlighted how weak accounting and reporting practices deny local leaders the opportunity to fix problems before they deteriorate into crisis and scandal,” said Chiang. “The lack of transparency provides a breeding ground for unchecked spending, corruption, and fiscal mismanagement.”

Last month, Governor Jerry Brown signed AB 1248, a bill sponsored by Controller Chiang and authored by Assemblyman Ken Cooley (D-Rancho Cordova), which calls for the Controller’s Office to work with local governments to develop statewide internal control guidelines.

A copy of the letter, along with a list of all non-compliant cities and special districts can be found here. All 58 counties are current on their reporting requirements, therefore none were included in today’s mailing.

Read a version of this press release in Spanish.

For more news, please follow the Controller on Twitter at @CAController, and on Facebook at California State Controller’s Office.

You may also like


Bobby Lott Oct 22, 2013 - 12:40 pm

That is the State of California… find anyway to screw you! Stand your ground Chief and show the state you are right!

Petitor Veritatis Oct 22, 2013 - 12:41 pm

Maybe the disputed report and the fire chief’s response will shut the ding-a-ling up.


24 Hours Ago

The CCT is reporting:

The financially troubled East Contra Costa Fire District is among dozens of government agencies that are late submitting mandatory financial documents to the state.

The state Controller’s Office this week issued a final warning letter to the fire agency, one of 117 special districts and nine cities that missed the deadline for filing accounting reports required of local governments each year.

All are one year or more overdue even though they received certified letters notifying them that they’re facing a financial penalty.

East Contra Costa Fire has yet to provide a so-called financial transactions report for the 2011-12 fiscal year, the deadline for which was Oct. 18, 2012.

The state Attorney General’s Office already is involved, having notified the fire district that it will forfeit $5,000 in state funds.

FreeClues Oct 22, 2013 - 6:54 pm

I’ve heard that when you don’t pay your property tax bill they notify you too. They even put it in the newspaper. Sometimes that’s info is not up to speed. If the district said it filed we don’t need P V to call people names. I believe the truth will come without looking for it.

Steve Smith Oct 24, 2013 - 12:37 am

The State Controller’s Office has admitted their error in placing ECCFPD on the list.

Comments are closed.